Moonstone: The Boy Who Never Was by Sjön

This seemed like it was pretty expensive for a 2-hour listen, but I’ve read a couple of Sjön’s prior works and they are exquisite (“From the Mouth of the Whale”  and “The Blue Fox”)     So okay – I went for it.

Imagine Iceland circa 1918 and a teenage boy who has to earn his living as a male prostitute.   The story opens with young Mani Steinn graphically involved in his general occupation, then goes into his yearning for a woman,  Sóla G,  after which it turns to a bizarre notion of seeing his own head in a casket.    It’s also about music,  motorcycles, movies and the Spanish flu and has a twist at the end which is truly unforgettable.

Moonstone:  The Boy Who Never Was
by Sjön  (Iceland)
2016 / 160 pages
read by Vikas Adam 2h 6m
Rating:  8.7  / historical fiction
(warning – a gay child prostitute is the main character)  


“The Boy” of the title is Mani,  a parentless soul who lives with his great-grandmother and her sister in Reykjavík, Iceland.   At age 15 or 16 he loves movies and what he learns about the world from them.  Although silent and with a very dark  atmosphere,  Mani watches movies obsessively at two theaters.  His favorite movie is the 17-hour long “The Vampires”  by Louis Feuillade.

(Is this like the books about girls who read too much fiction and it ends up messing with their real lives?  – I suspect there’s a connection – see Northanger Abbey by Jane Austen or a few others.  But where those are somewhat comic,  there is not one humorous line in  Moonstone.)

But these movies,  grim as they are,  are sometimes  preferable to what he learns in his real world of 1918 – about his customers and about the plague of deaths from the flu epidemic brought by seamen fighting  the Great War in Europe which rages on.   And then there’s the the volcano,  Katla, which spewed more fire and smoke that same year.

One night “the boy”  accepts a customer and says his name is Mani Steinn which the foreigner pronounces as “Moonstone.”

At the movies Mani meets a girl who looks just like his favorite actress (Irma Vep of The Vampires)  and the two of them are friends although she’s from the upper class and he’s from the very lowest of the low.  All classes can go to the movies and it seems to like the movies are open 24/7 and Mani can go almost any time.  They’re black and white,  and silent.    His movie life and his real life get enmeshed.  Mani is a true outsider – an outsider of outsiders.  Yet he survives in his own fashion – and so  does Iceland in  getting its independence from Denmark that same year,  1918.


Katla in 1918

The narrative is loose, dreamy,  very grim and somewhat fantastical at times.   It is beautifully written with even some poetry included from time to time – by Sjön.  But it’s really hard to stay focused on the book – which is possibly explained at the end.  Brilliant.

The ending is a knockout going from the hellish streets of Reykjavík to much much later and far away and back again,  presenting a cycle in a way.  And in the turning we’ve forgotten all about Mani/ Moonstone – the boy who wasn’t.

I’m a bit hesitant about recommending this one because it has some really graphic homosexual scenes in it but if you think you can get past that,  it’s worth it.

This entry was posted in 2023 Fiction. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Moonstone: The Boy Who Never Was by Sjön

  1. Lisa Hill says:

    A lovely review: yes, I agree about the graphic scenes, but I liked the way the author puts it up front: it’s as if he’s saying, deal with it or don’t read my book.

    Liked by 1 person

    • He did do that – right up front. And thank you but I see I ought to proofread my blogs a bit more. lol


      • Lisa Hill says:

        Ha ha, don’t we all! I’m having trouble with my eyes at the moment and a lot of the time I’m reading through a blur and I don’t see all the typos that I routinely make…
        But hey, I don’t think that blogs have to run to the same standard as publications that have an army of editors and proof-readers to help them out.
        And if I make a mistake, I’d rather someone quietly corrected it (if it’s a comment on someone else’s blog) or told me about it if it’s on mine, so that I can fix it:)

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s