I rarely watch movies, this might be the second movie I’ve watched this year and it’s 2 days from December. Oh well. I’m not impressed. I watched because I think I saw it back in 1986, when it was released. I was confusing it with the Dead Poet’s Society and although I still think I saw Seize the Day, I was obviously not impressed then and I hadn’t read the book.
The movie was good for what it was. But it wasn’t anywhere nearly what the book by Saul Bellow was. Robin Williams was excellent in his overly-dramatic role, and the rest of the cast was wonderful ((in my ignorant opinion). The movie even managed to catch a bit of the book’s lighthearted approach without which it would all descend into gloom and doom. But I felt like I was being given a 90-minute version of a rather thought-provoking 4-hour book (a novella). It felt condensed with a lot of the meaning left out and the obligatory addition o skin.
There have been movies I’ve wanted to see over the years, Cloud Atlas for one. But if this is any indication of what happens to books I enjoy, I have to say I’m just as happy to skip them. Movies which were originally intended to be movies are probably a LOT better unless you’re looking for a very picturesque rendition and a seriously cut version – like Pride and Prejudice.
Doctor Zhivago by Boris Pasternak is a favorite book and then I watched the movie. Tragically pathetic. And Belizaire the Cajun is a favorite movie and it was never a book. The Wanderers is another favorite and it only claims to be “based on” a book. It is kind of based on Richard Price’s first novel, but … Finally, Blade Runner is a brilliant novel by Philip K. Dick (Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?) and made into an entirely different brilliant movie by Ridley Scott. I could go on with a few more movies but like I said, I watch very few.
See? I do enjoy some movies but, based on my preferences, I doubt I’ll watch or go to more. I can’t imagine going to see any of those playing within 50-60 miles now.
Try Cloud Atlas. It is very beautiful. I don’t know if it captured the spirit of the book because I have yet to read it, but as a movie it’s a wonderful experience. Some people find it slow and boring though.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think it might be better to wait longer between book and movie for some movies. How would Cloud Atlas be on a tiny screen? – Mac Air?
How tiny? If it’s about 8-11″ it may look fine because my tablet is between those measurements, but sure a bigger screen is better when it comes to movies. 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person