Murder on Astor Place ~ by Victoria Thompson

I read this for the 4-Mystery Addicts reading group and it’s a book I would never have picked up on my own,  but it was pretty good.   Fwiw,  I’m getting kind of tired of reading about women in trouble though –  about their lives of hardship and pain and so on.  They always seem to be victims of something –  even the “strong” women due it against sexist adversity.

Although Thompson is usually considered to be a writer of “cozy”  mysteries,  this one gets quite gritty and sordid  in subject matter.   With “cozies”  crimes don’t  actually happen in the narrative.  They virtually always in the past or off-stage,  so to speak,  with the story line following the efforts of the detectives after the fact.  Another thing is there’s also an amateur detective as well as a police presence somewhere.   Murder on Astor Place fits.



Murder on Astor Place
by Victoria Thompson 
2015 / 288 pages
read by Callie Beaulieu –  8h 32m
rating:  B+ /  historical-procedural
Gaslight Mysteries #1 


We’re in  New York circa 1895-96 and the papers are full of Teddy Roosevelt as Police Commissioner.  This was the height of the Gilded Age which,  although I’ve read better descriptions of it and some novelists work it into the story better,  Thompson uses it quite well and it’s front and center to the main plot –  probably the plots of all the novels in the series.

This is the first in a series so I expected some good character development for the lead detectives in order to set up an over-arching plot.  There is that –  Sarah Brandt, our amateur detective is a midwife by trade, but that’s illegal in the city at the time so she’s not exactly a fan of the police.  Sarah is


“Petit Chateau” Vanderbilt Mansion at 660 Fifth Avenue. It was built in 1882 and served as an influential example for other Gilded Age mansions, while also demonstrating the visual outpouring of wealth.

the widow of a murder victim and estranged from her prominent family.

One night while delivering a baby,  she discovers the body of a 16-year old girl.  This turns out to be the sister of a past friend.  The girl  had been strangled.  Sarah  starts doing a bit of investigation of her own.

This activity brings her into contact with Police Detective Frank Malloy who is a  good at his job.  He fears for Sarah’s safety and rather resents her interference.

It turns out Alicia VanDamm, the deceased,  was the daughter of very prominent couple,  Cornelius and Felicia VanDamm –  and Alicia was pregnant.  And then it turns out the Russian midwife is also dead.  The tale goes on.  There are a few family members and servants and gossipy society ladies to investigate and interview.  Also,  there’s an underlying hint of a possible romance between Sarah and Frank.

The historical part is light although Thompson certainly did some research – sometimes it shows,  sometimes not.  The New York police department of the era was notably corrupt  and Roosevelt took some measures although he and his faction tooted his own more than was probably deserved.    Thompson has an extensive oeuvre with romance and mystery series going back to 1985.

Bottom line –  I did enjoy the lead characters of Sarah and Frank,  the mystery was good enough with a few twists,  the history was light but accurate – and sometimes  new –  for instance Astor Place is a real street,  very short,  located in Lower Manhattan.   I’d like to find time to read Book 2,  Murder on St. Mark’s Place,  but …  we’ll see.

This entry was posted in 2023 Fiction. Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Murder on Astor Place ~ by Victoria Thompson

  1. Dagny says:

    I absolutely love this series! Recently finished #15. Of the fifteen I’ve read, there was maybe one which I didn’t enjoy quite as much as the others and the last few – it seems they just keep getting better and better! Of course a lot of it is because I’ve become so fond of all the characters. The ones where the mystery portion is personal to the characters are extra special to me. If your library system has access to “Overdrive” (which I think is nationwide, but maybe not), they have the next three in audio.

    Another series set in NYC at about the same time frame is Rhys Bowen’s Molly Murphy mysteries.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. My library has Overdrive but only a smallish collection – also, only for my iPad, not my MacBook which is how I listen. MacBook has spoiled me for the sound quality. 😦 So I’ve kind of abandoned OD. It’s the same with their ebooks – their own formatting or something.

    That’s okay – I watch sales and pretty much get what I want. Glad to hear you enjoyed the books – I think I do but … we’ll see. (Ever since Monica Ferris slowed down I’ve been at a kind of loss for a good cozy series.) –

    Liked by 1 person

    • Dagny says:

      I read a couple of Monica Ferris’ Needlecraft mysteries but never got really interested in the main character. I looked her up though and found out she worked with Margaret Frazer on the first few Sister Frevisse mysteries and I really liked those.

      Liked by 1 person

      • I tried a Needlecraft Christmas book by Ferris (Cruel Yule) and I thought it was funny – I proceeded to Book 1 and ran through the whole series in a few years. Waiting for another one now.

        Alexander McCall Smith is another cozy series I like – I’ve read every one of them since they started – as they came out. The #1 Ladies Detective Agency – not his other series.

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s