All the Light We Cannot See

51pNBRwj74L._SL300_All the Light We Cannot See
by Anthony Doerr
*2014 / 531 pages (Kindle)
*Read by Zach Appelman / 16h 2m
Rating: 8 / historical fiction (WWII)
(both listened and read)

Opening Doerr’s second novel which one of my reading groups (BookiesToo) chose for our December 15th selection (I wasn’t thrilled to find another war book) – American bombers are dropping their load on the small city of Saint Malo in northern France.   Fortunately,  the front lines and bombing raids are not the focus. Instead, two  children growing up under very different circumstances during the war years are the focus of this  mesmerizing work of historical fiction –  emphasis on the fiction,  I’d say.

Mesmerizing?  Yup – and charming and fast-paced and long and cozy in its own way.

The structure is your basic “here’s now” alternating with “how did we get here” (backstory) and goes on into “the rest of the story.”  That’s okay – it’s a good structure if the story will hold up – this one does.   In fact,  Doerr uses it to extremely good effect with the story in the frame time (August, 1944)  going fairly slowly and with quite a bit of suspense and the backstory giving the reader all the background insight into what’s transpiring.

A more interesting aspect of the structure is that the tale is broken into 12 major Parts which alternate the time frames and within those parts there are  178 (yes!)  very short chapters.  These provide a significant amount of white space as well as making the story move faster than it might otherwise.  There are lots of little cliff-hangers –

The “frame” story, as I suppose it is, opens in 1944 as Saint Malo, Brittany,  on the coast of northern France which is  being bombed by Americans finishing the fight with the Germans for control of that city.   This is two months after D-Day.  They have dropped fliers to the occupants of the city warning them to leave.

And through all this the themes of love and yearning are woven.  The changes the long war has brought have the characters desiring simple food and safety number one, but they are also remembering the past and looking to the  future – a desire for communication with far away loved ones is big.   And in any story about the Nazis, the theme of  good vs evil can not be far removed.

In August of 1944 Marie Laure LeBlanc is a 16-year old motherless blind girl who lives in the city with her great-uncle Etienné and great-aunt Madame Manec, the housekeeper.  Marie’s father has made her a scale model of the city to locate herself. Also, she can hear the bombers coming.  She finds a paper on a shelf – then an egg-sized stone.

A few blocks away,   the 18-year old Werner Pfennig wakes up in the Hotel of Bees.  He is a part of the German occupation trying to hold on to their last bits.  They have a very large gun with which to fight off the air raid.  He hides in the cellar as directed and readies himself at the radio.



Saint Malo with the steeple

And then the story goes back to 1934 when 6 year-old Marie Laure lived in Paris with her widowed father who worked at the Museum of Natural History.    She listens to a story told at the museum about a priceless stone called the “Sea of Flames”  which also carries an incredible load of  bad luck.  A month later Marie Laure is struck blind.  So now dad tutors Marie in all manner of things, and built her the model neighborhood to practice finding her way in.   After some reluctance she excels.

Meanwhile in Germany at the time an intellectually gifted orphan,  Werner Pfennig,  is found and trained in radio engineering and mathematics for the Nazi  efforts. He excels.

Cached between the tales of Marie Laure and Werner is the story of the blue diamond,  the “Sea of Flames,”  a precious stone which Marie’s father helped to guard at the Museum and which he helped to conceal.  It is Major Reinhold von Rumpel who wants that stone for the Reich so the tale of his tracking is also interspersed throughout.  The stone story is a fabrication but the Nazis were notorious plunderers:

Another story threading through the tale of the two children is that of the women in Saint Malo who form a kind of Resistance to the Germans occupying their city.

And the course of the war can be told as Werner goes from having the very best at his disposal to having less and giving up more for the führer.  And his friend Frederick has some problems,  big ones.

I hate to say it this way,  but  All the Light We Cannot See is “lyrically” written.  There’s a nice  rhythm and an intelligent vocabulary at work here.   It scans easily and the audio narrator,  Zac Appelman, does an admirable job.

Goodreads – lots of info:


2 Responses to All the Light We Cannot See

  1. Jeff says:

    I loved this book. A story about the Nazi occupation that was not unbearably grim. I loved how the scale model helps her learn to navigate the city and I was also pleased with the way the author alternated viewpoints. A totally excellent book that I would heartily recommend.


  2. Yup – I really enjoyed this one and that’s kind of weird because I was just ranting about historical fiction which focuses on the fiction. So what’s the difference between this and “The Miniaturist” (Jessie Burton)? I can’t put my finger on the difference – I think the structure really added something and the main plot line was less “romance” and more wartime living experience. Also, were fewer contemporary social issues involved –


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s