The Bone Clocks – review


The Bone Clocks
by David Mitchell
2014 / 640 pages
read by Jessica Ball, Leon Williams, Colin Mace, Steven Crossley, Laurel Lefkow, Anna Bentinck – 24h 30m
rating: 7  / sci-fi- fantasy

Oh what can I say about a genius author whose latest book does not live up to the expectations of  the last?

I loved reading Cloud Atlas – loved it – both times – text and audio versions – the whole thing.  I also loved The Thousand Autumns of Jacob de Zoet (with a small exception) , but I wasn’t so crazy about Mitchell’s earlier Black Swan Green.

I think  I expected “great things” from The Bone Clocks and,  well,  for the most part it’s very good  – but when the plot devolves into body-snatchers and zombie-like activities including a war between the semi-immortal good guys (the Horologists)  and their equivalent bad guys (The Anchorites) – well  –  those parts are just not my usual cuppa  (lol).  – And I had the same reaction to one part of  The Thousand Autumns of Jacob de Zoet, fwiw.  With The Bone Clocks there were times I didn’t know why in the world I was continuing to read the extreme nonsense  – I very nearly unplugged the earbuds, but I’m very glad  I didn’t because the tale improved a bunch and then wound up nicely.   🙂

Overall this is a very interesting baggy door-stopper  –  it’s overly convoluted and, allowing for one really stupid part,  it’s compelling and fun mostly – great story-telling.

Part 1:  In 1984 the 16-year old Holly Sykes, who sometimes hears “radio voices,” runs away from home to be with her much older boyfriend.  This doesn’t quite work out,  but during her time away she meets (or there are flashbacks of) some rather strange people who will reappear throughout the novel.   Holly is the main character in this novel which stretches from 1984 (an ominous year, eh?) to 2043 when she’s 75 years old,  but there are several other featured 1st person narrators.  Except for a cliff-hanger ending,  Part 1 is an introductory novella of its own.

Part 2:  In 1991 Hugo Lamb is a “posh boy” playing at being a student at Cambridge and skiing in Switzerland where he gets in trouble with his buddies and so he, like Holly, runs away.  Hugo and Holly meet on the slopes,  fall in love and then, also like Holly,  Hugo  has mysterious visitations.

Moving along to Part 3, 2004, where Holly is now partnered with Ed Brubeck, a war correspondent, and they have a young daughter named Aoife (ee’ -fay)  who leaves her home and disappears (lots of disappearing kids in this novel),  the parents panic and Holly saves the day by means of some kind of “occult?”  communication.

There are two other major characters, Crispin Hershey,  an aging raging has-been author in 2015, and Marinus,  a so-called immortal Horologist who was Holly’s psychologist when she was a child and now, in 2025, explains the workings of the “war of the semi-immortals.”    I really enjoyed Crispin,  not Marinus so much – gender changing was hard.

I have no idea whether to recommend this or not.  The overly clever narrative is sometimes irritating – see the Wood review:

James Wood in the New Yorker.

Thinking about it I wonder if Mitchell didn’t tell his children strange stories about what happens to children who run away or wander off and developed it for a larger, possibly more mature,  audience.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s